Documentary Evidence www.documentaryevidence.co.uk

Mute Presents Short Circuit

The Roundhouse, London 13 / 14 May 2011








Mute Short Circuit

The Roundhouse, London 13 May 2011

'We just thought it's an opportunity to get everybody together in one place and have a nice time,' is how Daniel Miller, in typically understated fashion, described the two days' worth of Mute Records artists at this year's Short Circuit festival (source: The Wire issue 327, Invisible Jukebox). The 'everybody' he referred to consisted of a huge chunk of the Mute / Grey Area / NovaMute roster from years gone by, and made for a jaw-droppingly exciting prospect - Erasure (and 'special guests'), DJ sets from Martin L. Gore and Andy Fletcher from Depeche Mode, a DJ set from Moby, Recoil, Nitzer Ebb, Richie 'Plastikman' Hawtin, Richard H. Kirk, The Balanescu Quartet, Komputer, Simon Fisher Turner, Poppy & The Jezebels, Polly Scattergood... and so on into the newbies, Beth Jeans Houghton, S.C.U.M., Big Deal and Josh T. Pearson (performing the songs of Mute). It was the type of event that a Mute fan could only ever dream about, with lots of surprises to make even the most casual fan go weak at the knees; I literally felt queasy all afternoon at work. The feeling was only neutralised after I bagged my white vinyl 7" of The Normal's 'Warm Leatherette / T.V.O.D.', an exclusive Vorwärts CD, advance copies of The Balanescu Quartet and I Start Counting / Fortran 5 / Komputer compilations, and a Mute tote bag of course. I did feel a little conspicuous without a Depeche Mode t-shirt on, mind, given the prevalence of fans around me.

My only concern, heading to Chalk Farm Underground after work, was about sound quality. The Roundhouse is an historical building from Britain's dominance in the industrial age and an iconic concert location, being the venue where The Ramones first played in London. I've been here three times before, twice to concerts, and I've always thought that the sound quality and acoustics in the venue were appalling. The only time it sounded good was when David Byrne installed his Playing The Building contraption here a few years go, whereupon the natural cylindrical cavern-ness of the building leant itself perfectly to his installation.

Because of family commitments I could only make the first day, so I missed out on the fuller line-up that Saturday 14 May offered. But I did get to see Komputer, Nitzer Ebb, a DJ set from Moby and a live performance from Recoil, the long-running project of ex-Depeche Mode soundsmith Alan Wilder. I would have liked to have seen all of The Balanescu Quartet but because this was a festival there's a thing called sequencing which means bands you want to see can often be on at the same time so you have to make a choice, in my case Nitzer Ebb. Because of capacity constraints, I didn't even get into the Studio Theatre for any of the quartet's performance, but I gather they played 'Autobahn'. Never mind; I'll content myself with having seen them at the Royal Festival Hall a few years ago as part of Patti Smith's Hendrix event. And as for the events in the twilight hours? Well, last trains back home saw those ambitions slip well and truly off my radar.

In the lobby, Irmin Schmidt and Kumo's Flies, Guys and Choirs installation had me feeling well and truly creeped out by the sibilant rasps and chittering, insistent sounds. Looking at the glass ceiling around the lobby, I saw a small bluebottle trying to find a way through the horizontal glass. I wondered if it was aware of how ironic this was given the insectoid cacophany buzzing underneath him.

Down in the Studio Theatre, Simon Leonard was beset by vocoder problems, but he pressed on regardless, opening with a new Komputer track 'Minimum', which was a fairly apt description for what they did on stage, David Baker singing the chorus of 'Do the minimum,' with his hands behind his back in a casual stance. It was a pose he adopted for most of the 40 minute set, only moving his hands to sprinkle occasional riffs from his Korg synth. To me they looked like Egon Spengler from Ghostbusters (the frail-looking Leonard) and Gary Glitter (Baker; but such awesome triangular sideburns and when I bumped into him afterwards he's a lot shorter in person) in orange boiler suits, but it befitted the music. It's been years since I heard 'Looking Down On London', well before the call of the City made me want to work here, but it's sound was instantly recognisable and pretty moving; a video of the sun setting on the City appeared behind them and stayed up for most of their set. It was then onto I Start Counting's 'Letters To A Friend', a song I haven't played for about 15 years, followed by a heavy version of Fortran 5's 'Heart On The Line' with Leonard's troubled vocoder replacing that girl from Miranda Sex Garden. 'Like A Bird' was beautifully delicate. There was a storming dancey update of 'Still Smiling' with burbling acid-esque flourishes while the pulsing Kraftwerkian 'Valentina' descended into corruscating white noise. A heavy 'Million Headed Monster' was a welcome encore, straddling the angry and the euphoric effortlessly.

I don't know enough of Recoil's back catalogue these days to recognise individual tracks, but the cacophanous gospel / hip-hop beats and crushing bass-heavy noise I walked into in the Main Space dispelled any lingering doubts I may have had about The Roundhouse's sound quality. Edgy imagery provided thoughts of alienation / fear / angst / urban terror. On the right of the stage was Alan Wilder, still dressed in a sharp suit like it's Depeche Mode circa '93 but an awesome sonic / visual palette is nonetheless in evidence, ably supported by Paul 'PK' Kendall. When the dirty detuned 4/4 beats kicked in and fragile synths gave way to the 12" mix of 'Never Let Me Down' the Depeche Mode fans in the crowd went apeshit, and all of a sudden you're just begging for Dave Gahan to come on stage, but this is instrumental Mode-hugging only. He's just teasing. 'You know the routine, let's go!' Wilder-the-showman says (a bit cheesily), urging the crowd to wave their arms from side to side in a style familiar from so many DM gigs. Lurid hotel porno peepshow videos and dark sounds fill The Roundhouse and we're into snatches of 'In Your Room'; he was playing to a DM-loving crowd after all. Recoil were at their most interesting when heading into the Autechre-style electronica of 'Shunt', which expanded out into an entirely logical 'Warm Leatherette' segue. Alas, there was no sign of Daniel Miller on stage. It was just the record, just Wilder teasing again.

And then, from nowhere, Douglas McCarthy was on stage for 'Faith Healer', impossibly cool in shades and revelling in the track's manic preacher-style delivery, while dense distorted beats and sounds accompanied his stalking moves. Bon Harris, Jason Payne and someone else come on stage for the Ebb's 'Family Man', which was an altogether dystopian, noisy and gorgeously threatening affair, all percussion heavy from the Ebb guests. On a personal level, that was pretty thrilling. The expanded line-up stayed on stage for something which snatched part of 'Personal Jesus' with Doug doing the 'reach out and touch faith' part like he was Gahan's natural successor.

Nitzer Ebb's backdrop, The Roundhouse 13/05/2011

For me, one of the natural attraction of the first day was being able to see Nitzer Ebb. Until today the closest I got was when they were due to appear at the Phoenix Festival in Stratford-upon-Avon, as I could just about hear the bands from my parents' porch, but I think they pulled out at the last minute. And then, after Big Hit, they appeared to split anyway, thwarting any hopes I then had of seeing them live. Even when they reformed two years ago, I couldn't make any of the dates. Nitzer Ebb were my first foray towards music's underground, so on a personal level seeing them live was a dream come true.

They arrived on stage to 'Getting Closer' and ended with a rousing 'I Give To You', and before I know it it's 1992 and I've been dumped by yet another girlfriend. In between, 'Murderous' and 'Let Your Body Learn' highlight the enduring and vaguely inexplicable energy of Douglas McCarthy, Bon Harris and Jason Payne, who tonight are dressed like Boardwalk Empire mobsters, while 'Control I'm Here' had the crowd pogo-ing madly as McCarthy urged the crowd on. 'Lightning Man' and 'Godhead' were delivered with edgy disdain; during the former McCarthy waved a hand like he was a New Orleans carnival host; during the latter, amid the heaviest, most bludgeoningly over-the-top head-bangingest section, he literally flounced along the stage. 'Down On Your Knees', 'Once You Say' and 'Payroll' from the recent Industrial Complex had the crowd whipped into a frenzy and I began to see the 'sex' in the Ebb sound for the first time (especially during 'Payroll' when McCarthy was lewdly shouting 'You wanna suck it?'); previously I thought it was just unbridled rage and I'm not sure quite how I missed that somewhat obvious dimension to their robust sound. Moby and Martin Gore were also watching, but I doubt that they felt quite like I did as I found myself looking happily in on my troubled teenage years.

Seeing Moby DJ his way through his back catalogue and thudding dance track after dance track reminds you that he is, after everything he's done and all the genres he's traversed, still fundamentally in love with dance music, still the bald New York techno DJ. Unassuming in t-shirt and jeans he had The Roundhouse crowd rocking like it was way later than 10.00pm, manic imagery of night-time Manhattan skyscrapers and jumpcut shots of Moby himself providing the backdrop. I've stood just about as close to the guy who, quite honestly, I wish was my best mate, and I've danced my socks off like I just discovered techno again, and that's fine by me. He finished his set, entirely logically, with 'Thousand' while Richie Hawtin set up his laptop, whereupon I proved for the first and indeed last time that it's impossible to dance to that track.

Moby, at the conclusion of 'Thousand', The Roundhouse 13/05/2011

While Moby's DJ set was edging darkly toward 'Thousand', and just before I left, Daniel Miller walked past me. I shook his hand and thanked him, though he didn't realise it, for tonight, for the music Mute have produced, for his creative vision and for providing me with an escape from top ten chart hell. It is at this point that I could probably stop writing for Documentary Evidence; my work here is quite possibly done. I've met my hero, seen some idols and it's hard to see where to go from here.

(c) 2011 MJA Smith / Documentary Evidence