Documentary Evidence www.documentaryevidence.co.uk

Colin Newman

Not To








Not To | We Means We Starts (single)

Colin Newman 'Not To' LP artwork Colin Newman 'We Means We Starts' 7" artwork

album // Not To

4ad | lp cad201 | 01/1982 | track listing

1982's Not To was Wire guitarist / vocalist Colin Newman's third album for 4AD, following 1980's A-Z and the following year's Provisionally Entitled The Singing Fish, and found him working with friend and early bandmate Desmond Simmons (guitar, piano, recorded, vocals), Simon Gilham (bass, vocals) and Wire sticksman Robert Gotobed (drums, percussion). Not To was produced by Newman himself, and in, addition to guitar and vocals, he is also credited with playing piano, tabla, 'other vibes', percussion and effects.

Aside from the omnipresent steady drumming of Robert Gotobed, Not To also featured four collaborations with other former members of Wire; aside from the contribution of Bruce Gilbert's 'greatest hit' guitar on the song 'Indians!', these collaborations were all songs written by Wire post the recording of 154 just ahead of the band splitting up around 1980. 'Safe' is one of those tracks, here finding Newman co-writing with the occasionally-confrontational Wire bassist Graham Lewis; 'Safe' features almost Christmas-y percussion, neatly offsetting lots of droning guitar effects and a cloying sense of being anything but safe. 'Remove For Improvement' was written by Bruce Gilbert and Newman, and features oddly soulful vocals from Newman. Elsewhere on the song, gently shimmering guitar layers combine with an undertow of restless drumming from Gotobed and urgent bass from Gilham. Finally, '5/10', which was written by all four members of Wire consists of a murky backdrop of mutant squeaks, gentle noises, pondering bass, non-existant percussion and droning guitar textures. The piece threatens to develop into something concrete but is instead content to be similar to the tracks that characterised the more sonically adventurous experiments on 154. According to Newman, the versions he recorded for Not To varied substantially from those assembled with Wire.

Sticking with the experimental leanings of Seventies Wire's final album, Not To's opener, 'Lorries', feels like the natural successor to 154's seminal 'Map Ref. 41ºN 93ºW', listing out various European places in Newman's trademarked wry vocal style, while melodic bass melodies and layers of scratchy guitarwork envelop the lyrics; it could almost be a different arrangement of the same song, with different lyrics (and some German), and without the pre-announced chorus. The track featuring Bruce Gilbert, 'Indians!', showcases an uptight rhythm and those skeletal, clipped and distorted guitars, also featuring spirals of distant recorder from Simmons, chattering voices rising up from the background, a beat that only coalesces in the track's final throes, and a feeling that this may have been largely improvised.

Like a fair number of the Newman-penned tracks on Wire's early releases, Not To features lots of fast-paced numbers, such as 'Don't Bring Me Reminders' with its big, shouty chorus and sparse instrumentation. 'Don't Bring Me Reminders' has a naturally driving beat from Gotobed but the bass and guitar sections are filled with wide gaps, only a wayward staccato rhythm guitar line running in the background through most of the song. 'We want to see what's left of you,' is a classic Newman non-sequitur of a chorus, arriving with no direct linkage to the verses and sung anthemically by a choir of Newman, Simmons and Gilham. Similarly, '1, 2, 3, Beep, Beep' is a hyperactive mix of a skiffly beat, tinkling bell sounds and almost Latin guitar playing, Newman scarcely catching a breath during a long list of words and scenarios that are connected by the barest thread of narrative.

Things slow down somewhat on the album's title track. 'Not To' contains deep bass notes and shimmering guitar. Barely-there percussion and emotional swells – synths perhaps - rise up from the background, Newman's quizzical vocal giving this a sense of strained poignancy. 'We Meet Under Tables' exists somewhere between watery ska and waltz-time piano introspection, its enquiring chorus of 'what to say, where to go, who to know' drifting along above reflective piano notes and sparse bass and jazzy, swinging percussion.

The album closes with an unexpected cover of The Beatles's 'Blue Jay Way', penned by George Harrison and included on their Magical Mystery Tour album. The version recorded here takes the Indian mysticism evident on the original and parachutes in Newman's punkish vocal atop a droning, effects-enhanced backdrop of backward sound, tabla, simple drumming and stalking bass, making for something just as strange some twelve years after its recording.

read review

lp:
A1. Lorries
A2. Don't Bring Me Reminders
A3. You Me & Happy
A4. We Meet Under Tables
A5. Safe
A6. Trucculent Yet (sic)
B1. 5/10
B2. 1, 2, 3, Beep, Beep
B3. Not To
B4. Indians!
B5. Remove For Improvement
B6. Blue Jay Way

Not To | We Means We Starts (single)

Colin Newman 'We Means We Starts' 7" artwork Colin Newman 'Not To' LP artwork

single // We Means We Starts

4ad | 7" ad209 | 05/1982 | track listing

'We Means We Starts', recorded in the same sessions as those that produced Colin Newman's Not To album, is a nice, mostly upbeat pop track that doesn't sound a million miles away from the sleek sound that Wire would produce during their second coming. The song finds Newman deploying his finest wide-eyed, inquisitive vocal while a sparse, programmed beat edges ever forward beneath him. The song also features subtle percussion from Robert Gotobed, noodling piano and Simon Gilham's lumpy bass notes blended with Newman's own edgy guitar notes. There's a hazy, dreamy Eighties quality to this piece, and as tracks go, frankly it seems far too good not to have made it on to the Not To LP; it's well worth tracking down. 'We have what I would call an agreement / Never spoken but often broken,' is one of the matter-of-fact lines Newman sings here; never one to deliver what you might call 'regular' lyrics, no-one does quizzical indifference quite like Newman, and 'We Means We Starts' is a fine example.

A slightly different version of 'Not To' takes up the B-side, the principal difference being much more pronounced reverb on the spiky guitar notes and a mostly instrumental second half which is dominated by synth washes that rise to the surface more prominently compared to their comparative submersion on the album track. The more I hear this track, the more I'm reminded of 'Marooned' from Wire's Chairs Missing, possessing that song's same icy chill, the droning synths here sounding like whales trying to communicate while 'Marooned's protagonist flails and slips under the water.

read review

7":
A. We Means We Starts
B. Not To (Version)

(c) 2012 MJA Smith / Documentary Evidence